Chinese Herbs & Supplements

Chinese herbal remedy ‘just as effective as methotrexate against arthritis’ (Study, Medical News Today)

Lei Gong Teng (“Thunder God Vine”) and rheumatoid arthritis

Earlier this month came the exciting news that Chinese herb Lei Gong Teng (Tripterygium wilfordii Hook F) was found in study to be ‘just as effective as methotrexate against arthritis'” (Medical News Today). The study followed 204 patients and was published in the Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases this April.

Tripterygium hypoglaucum BotGardBln07122011B

Study conclusions

In treating active rheumatoid arthritis (RA), researchers found Tripterygium wilfordii Hook F (TwHF) monotherapy was no less effective than methotrexate (MTX) monotherapy; however, combined therapy was almost 25% more effective in relieving both tenderness/swelling of joints and improvement in other areas than either treatment alone. A follow-up study will need to be conducted for long-term assessment.

Thunder God Vine’s safety

Herbs can be powerful and exceptionally helpful with proper diagnosis and monitoring. It’s with this caution I mention Lei Gong Teng is an effective herb at the right dose and for the right patient–not for everyone. What does this mean? Go see your herbalist before you try this one!

Thunder God Vine is contraindicated in pregnancy, and considered toxic within Chinese medicine. Side effects can include gastrointestinal symptoms (e.g. vomiting, diarrhea), skin reactions, and missed menses. Caution is also advised for patients with compromised immune systems or osteoporosis. (Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database, Thunder God Vine).

RA Treatment

Western medicine generally recommends NSAIDs, drugs and steroids for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis; but there’s quite a few more treatment options out there:

    • Chinese medicine

In Chinese medicine, rheumatoid arthritis has different diagnoses whether it is in the acute or remission phase. Treatment, therefore, will differ depending on the stage of the disease. Traditionally, we combine acupuncture with herbal medicine, qigong and moxa (as appropriate) to treat the pain while clearing any excess, such as cold-type fluid retention, and tonifying underlying deficiency. For more on Chinese medicine’s approach, see, “Rheumatoid Arthritis and its Treatment with Chinese Medicine.”

    • Supplements

According to Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database, which queries clinical studies to find their information, the following natural medicines are considered “possibly effective” for the treatment of RA:

        • borage
        • bovine cartilage
        • cat’s claw
        • fish oil
        • glucosamine sulfate
        • superoxide dismutase
        • thunder god vine
        • vitamin D
        • vitamin E

Does this mean you should start taking these? No. 🙂 You know what I’m going to say already–go see your East Asian Medicine Practitioner, see a specialist. I mention these only to let you know there may be more options available to you than you were aware. (Beyond NMCD’s list, you might also be interested to read about UltraInfamX’s effect on swollen joints and C-reactive protein by Metagenics.)

    • Other holistic practices

Beyond Chinese medicine, there is also Naturopathy and Ayurveda (among other things!), both of which have their own unique system of diagnosis and treatment. For more information on Naturopathy and RA, see: Arthritis; for more on Ayurveda, see: The efficacy of Ayurvedic treatment for rheumatoid arthritis.

Are you starting to feel inspired yet? Go to it! Make an appointment today!

The top ten things to know about nutritional supplements...
Chinese Herbs & Supplements

Top 10 Things to Know about Supplements

Nutritional Supplements

At this point I’ve worked for two Chinese herbal pharmacies, one integrative pharmacy (providing a mixed offering of over-the-counter supplements and prescription pharmaceuticals) and have helped to market a US-based Chinese herbal distributor as well as a Western nutritional supplement manufacturer. Over this time, I’ve received a lot of questions about how to choose the right supplement and also seen a fair number of people randomly purchase and try supplements. In an attempt to address some of these questions, and also to explain why I don’t suggest buying and trying supplements without a practitioner recommendation, I’ve put together my…

Top Ten Things to Know about Supplements

1. Isolates are not whole foods.

One of the biggest differentiators within nutritional supplements is whether it is a whole-food product or not. What does this mean? Well, a nutrient, such as vitamin C, can be lab made and or isolated and concentrated – this would be considered an isolate. Or, a nutrient can be found in a whole food, such as the vitamin C found in an orange. In the case of a whole-food supplement, they’d take this natural source, extract it (for example, juice and dry) and then blend it into its final supplement that starts with an isolate (see #2). To supplement with a whole food, well that would mean simply eating the orange.

Obviously, eating an orange is the most natural form of nutrition; however eating a whole food also provides the lowest dose of any given nutrient. With an isolate, you can pack in much higher quantities of desired nutrients. A whole-food supplement is a pretty good go-between, providing slightly higher quantities of desired nutrients, while also getting all the beneficial cofactors (read: everything else that’s helpful and nutritious) in the food. Is one better than another? Not necessarily – it really depends on what’s needed.

2. Supplement Facts are different from Nutrition Facts.

Remember that bit where I said a whole-food supplement starts with an isolate? That’s because if a company is going to put a supplement on the market the FDA wants to be sure the public knows what they’re getting. Makes sense, right? But… two foods are never going to provide exactly the same amount of nutrients, right? So, a company has to start with a given amount of isolates so that they can guarantee there will be at least that much of a certain nutrient in the final product; the whole-food addition is just that, additional goodness. One of my favorite ‘supplement’ lines is HealthForce Nutritionals. What I love about their products is under their Nutrition Facts label I don’t see a list of nutrients; I see a list of foods– a sure sign I’m eating as naturally as possible. (Still would be nice to have an idea of how much of what was in a ‘supplement’– too bad they can’t test and list a random batch’s profile!)

3. Supplements come from various medical paradigms.

Just because you’re in the ‘Supplements’ section doesn’t mean they all work for the same reasons. You’ve got nutritional supplements, glandulars, Chinese herbs, Western herbs, homeopathic remedies, etc. I once had a customer question about hot flashes and what causes them. I explained how in Chinese medicine we understand that as the body ages, Kidney yin naturally declines, allowing yang to escape, which can result in hot flashes. A colleague who had been standing by then leaned into the conversation to say, “Yes, but I think she was asking what causes hot flashes?”

A man Laughing

(my pained, inside voice….)

Yes, it’s important to understand there is more than one theory on what causes illness and how to treat it. This difference will roll over to available treatment. Homeopathics can be very powerful medicine when prescribed appropriately; Chinese herbal medicine can be wonderful with the right diagnosis; Western supplements and herbs can be just what the doctor ordered when the whole picture is taken into consideration. One ‘sleep aid’ is not the same as another….

4. Homeopathics are energetic medicine.

I find homeopathic remedies so interesting! My first introduction to this medicine was with flower essences. In working with patients and customers, I’ve found many people don’t know how they’re made, but almost always are fascinated when I tell them. So, I thought I’d tell you, too!

Homeopathics are generally considered super safe because they’re a type of energetic medicine. They start off with a material–let’s say in the case of flower essences, a flower–from which they make a tincture by letting the crude material soak in an alcohol-water solution. Then they dilute it down, by taking only one drop of that solution and adding it to let’s say 9 parts alcohol-water solution. Then they take one drop of that diluted solution and add it to another 9 parts diluting material, etc. In the end you might be taking a remedy that has only one drop of the original tincture to 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 parts diluting material. (Seriously!) So, remember – the number on the side of the vial actually means something — it speaks to the concentration of the medicine, which is different than you’d think. The higher the number does not mean stronger medicine! Remember just then I said different supplements come from different medical paradigms? Well, in homeopathic remedies, a 6C, for example, targets something different than a 30C of the same remedy. The best part of homeopathics is that you don’t have to worry about drug interactions.

5. Homeopathics can work differently on different people.

Just an important side note about homeopathics–some people can have an opposite reaction to the remedy than intended. So, for example, a person taking a ‘calming’ homeopathic remedy might actually feel more anxious or excited after taking it. More reason to work with a homeopath before haphazardly pulling these off the shelves….

6. Vegans and vegetarians, check your sources.

And a last note on homeopathic remedies: They’re not necessarily going to tell you on the label if the remedy is vegetarian or vegan. A good example is extremely popular Oscillococcinum used by folks to treat flu symptoms. It would be great if anywhere on the packaging it indicated it was made with duck liver….

7. Nutritional supplements affect the body.

This one is hard for people to understand because supplements are so readily sold without question. It should be a no-brainer – but I mean nutritional supplements can affect the body in ways you were not expecting. Let me grab a bit on adverse reactions from a sample supplement, taken from Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database, an unbiased source for clinical information on the subject:

Orally, [supplement name] is generally well tolerated. Side effects are more common with higher doses and include flatulence, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, constipation, dry mouth, headache, mild insomnia, anorexia, sweating, dizziness, and nervousness (5231,9113,12231,14840,17123). Anxiety and tiredness have occurred in people with depression (5231,14841), and hypomania in people with bipolar disorder (5231). A case of mania with suicidal ideation has also been reported in an otherwise healthy patient (12231).

It’s true – a lot of people safely take this particular supplement, and they’re very happy with the positive effects. But as you can see, it would be extremely wise to only take it under the supervision and suggestion of an educated practitioner. For the right person, this supplement could really be the wrong choice.

8. Nutritional supplements can interfere with medication.

Another reason you want to make sure a healthcare professional is managing what you’re taking! And not just like… things get wonky. Women taking oral contraceptives and St. John’s Wort can find themselves getting pregnant–that kind of surprising ‘interference.’ Let’s not even get into drugs that affect the heart or mood….

9. Vitamins and minerals need their friends, too.

In Chinese herbal medicine, we break down a formula into parts of (my terms) who’s in charge, who’s their wingman, who’s their flanking support, and who gets them through the door into the party. Nutrition isn’t much different–let’s take calcium for example. We know we want calcium for the bones, and many agree 1200 mg is the lucky number. But, they found folks taking elemental calcium at higher doses showed increased risk for heart attack–the calcium was going to the blood vessels, not necessarily the bones. In contrast, when vitamin D is added, they find there doesn’t seem to be a significant problem with calcium going to the vessels. The take-home point? Food is always best. Next best, might be finding a synergistic formula in which the chief has a checks-and-balance system.

10. Citrate, glycinate, gluconate, carbonate, oh my!

This one is tough – you’ll find you can buy the same mineral in many different chelated forms: ~ citrate, ~ glycinate, etc. A chelated mineral is when they bind the mineral to an amino acid for the purpose of (supposedly) increasing bioavailability. It’s never clearly indicated what the difference is and/or which one to get. Again, there’s no right answer; and it’s different for each mineral. However, generally speaking when choosing between these you’re really choosing between digest-ability and absorb-ability. Some are easier on the digestion than others–remember these are rocks; and rocks aren’t the easiest to digest. So, depending on the strength of your gut, and the level of supplementation needed, you might choose one over another. Yet one more reason to leave it to the professionals….


Well, I hope this piece leaves you with a little more respect for what’s readily available to you in supporting your health, and a little more inspired to talk with a healthcare provider before trying to tackle it on your own. Concerned? Come on in for appointment!